Pensions - Articles - ACA welcomes CDC schemes but calls for robust governance

In a response to the DWP consultation on Collective Defined Contribution (CDC) schemes, submitted today, the Association of Consulting Actuaries (ACA) expressed support for the concept of CDC pension schemes. The ACA welcomed the Government’s desire to facilitate this new type of scheme for the Royal Mail and noted that similar designs might be helpful elsewhere too.

 In particular, the ACA sees a future possibility of a decumulation vehicle for members with DC pots at retirement who could benefit from some pooling of risk (but who do not wish to buy an annuity).

 However, the ACA is concerned that the potential market for CDC schemes is more limited now than it was when the idea was previously mooted during the ‘Defined Ambition’ initiative, as many employers have already moved from DB to DC schemes during the interim and may be reluctant to consider another change.

 ACA Chair, Jenny Condron, commented: “We welcome the option for a new type of pension scheme and CDC does have advantages that employers and members may benefit from where they choose to participate. It might be that the value of these arrangements arises sometime in the future when employers and employees realise that DC schemes with low levels of contributions fail to meet people’s needs.

 “We believe it is vital that any new schemes are subject to robust governance and regulation to protect members. There are obvious issues that arise from the pooling of risk across the membership, though these are an inherent feature of existing pension schemes.

 “There will also be a particular challenge in communicating these new and unfamiliar schemes to members to minimise the danger that member expectations are not delivered. Our members have the relevant skills for helping to run these types of pension schemes.”

 The ACA response notes that the key drivers of adequate pension provision are the level of contributions paid into the scheme over the years and the way that those contributions are invested, rather than the form of the pension arrangement. CDC schemes will remain reliant on adequate contributions and sound investment strategies to generate decent pensions, as is currently the case for DB and DC schemes. As an example, the Royal Mail proposals target a certain level of benefit but will sacrifice indexation if the investment returns do not prove sufficient to provide that target given the level of contributions paid.

 The ACA’s full response to the DWP consultation is here.

Back to Index

Similar News to this Story

Suggestion that State Pension Age should increase to 75
In response to the recent suggestion that the state pension age should increase to 75, Aegon calls for Government to confirm pension freedoms will be
GMP Equalisation soars to top of Pension Schemes To Do List
New figures from Equiniti reveal that GMP Equalisation has rocketed in importance for pension schemes following the landmark Lloyd’s case earlier this
XPS launch Competitive Tendering support for Trustees
In June 2019 the Competitions and Markets Authority (CMA) published its Order which implements the remedies that were set out in the CMA’s final repor

Site Search

Exact   Any  

Latest Actuarial Jobs

Actuarial Login

 Jobseeker    Client
Reminder Logon

APA Sponsors

Actuarial Jobs & News Feeds

Jobs RSS News RSS


Be the first to contribute to our definitive actuarial reference forum. Built by actuaries for actuaries.