By Anna Hicks, Principal, LCP
The Rolls-Royce UK Pension Fund, for example, completed buy-out for all 36,000 members less than 12 months after signing a £4.3 billion full buy-in with Pension Insurance Corporation, with LCP advising the Trustee on the buy-in and subsequent buy-out. That timetable isn’t the new normal and it will not be possible for every scheme. But it does underline a broader point: schemes that prepare well, negotiate the right terms and line up the operational detail early can put themselves in a much stronger position.
Get buy-out ready before the buy-in
The schemes best placed to move quickly are often those that have treated buy-out readiness as a priority, not a post-transaction clean-up exercise. That means investing time before the buy-in in data quality, governance and operational planning.
Data is particularly important. If data cleansing is undertaken before the buy-in and the benefits are clearly and accurately documented in a benefit specification, there will be fewer issues to resolve after the buy-in and before policies can be issued. If significant cleansing is required, the post transaction phase can take much longer.
GMP equalisation is another area to consider early. Some schemes will complete the calculations and implement benefit changes before buy-out, while others may be able to agree that the insurer implements any resulting benefit changes afterwards. Either way, responsibilities and a clear plan to complete the work should be agreed before the transaction is signed.
Where there is surplus, early alignment between trustee and sponsor can also be crucial. Decisions about how surplus will be used, including any member benefit uplifts, can affect the wind-up timetable. If those discussions are left until late in the process, this can delay the project. Similarly, any decisions regarding Trustee protections post wind-up can be agreed from the outset to avoid delays later in the process.
Lock in the insurer’s timetable
The competitive phase of a transaction process is when there is greatest leverage with insurers to agree key priorities, including timescales for the post transaction activity. If the ambition is to move quickly to buy-out, the timetable should be part of the commercial discussion, not something discussed after contracts are signed.
This should include target dates and agreed timescales for the insurer’s key actions, such as data review periods, administration and payroll onboarding, and drafting and issue of individual policy documents. Where appropriate, these commitments could be reflected in the contractual documents, including potential penalties for missing key deadlines.
Maintain momentum after signing
Once the buy-in is signed, the focus needs to shift quickly from transaction execution to project delivery. The post-transaction phase should be proactively managed by someone who has led these projects before, with clear ownership of actions, deadlines and risks across the trustee, sponsor, insurer, administrator and advisers.
Larger schemes may also have more scope to negotiate bespoke transition arrangements with insurers. That could include continuity of administration teams or agreed deviations from the insurer’s standard processes and timescales. These arrangements can make a real difference where the objective is to move quickly to buy-out. Smaller schemes may need to work within more standard insurer processes, but they can still benefit from clear milestones, active management and early escalation where progress stalls. Clear governance also matters: decisions may need to be made quickly, so trustees and sponsors should know in advance who can approve what, and when.
What should trustees and sponsors take away?
A quick transition from buy-in to buy-out depends on more than scheme size or insurer capacity. A fast transition to buy-out can be achieved when trustees, sponsors and their advisers have clear objectives and drive the project forward to hit target timelines.
Trustees and sponsors should ensure that:
Their data is in good shape and benefits clearly and accurately documented before approaching the market
Resource and engagement from their existing administrators have been secured to deliver the agreed tasks
The buy-out timetable has been agreed with the insurer and clear roles and responsibilities have been pinned down
Any decisions that require trustee and sponsor alignment have been agreed e.g. principles for dealing with surplus funds and Trustee protections that will exist beyond wind-up
A specialist advisor has been appointed to drive the post-transaction process forward.
The schemes that are well prepared and have considered tasks above will be best placed to move quickly. Fast buy-out is not achieved by hoping the post-buy-in process will run smoothly. It requires clear commitments before signing and active management afterwards, with an experienced specialist keeping insurer actions on track, spotting blockers early and maintaining momentum until the final member policy is in place.
|
