Articles - How to assess diversity of thought in asset managers

One of the core pillars of a well-constructed portfolio is diversification. Whether in terms of the sources of return or the risks of individual assets, diversification aims to mitigate risk and reduce portfolio level volatility, which can improve overall risk-adjusted returns. One of the lesser known facts is that for our manager researchers, we extend this concept of diversification to investment teams. When we evaluate actively managed funds, one of the metrics we consider is diversity of thought in the investment teams.

 By David Yao, FIA, Senior Investment Consultant at Hymans Robertson

 In particular, we assess whether the team are all from similar firms in the industry or have worked together for so long that they could be susceptible to group think, which can result in unchallenged decision-making. We often look for evidence of external hires or junior professionals who can provide some challenge to the investment ideas under consideration and prompt more rigorous debate.

 Diversity of thought is closely linked to diversity and inclusion – as evidenced by the case studies discussed in this paper, the investment teams with a high success rate are typically those that have smart people who think differently, who have been trained differently, went to different schools, have different knowledge bases and have different genders and ethnic backgrounds. Global economies and supply chains are now so inter-linked that challenges or regulations in one country can have significant effects on the economy of another country. A diverse and well-networked group of professionals is likely to have the best chance of responding to such challenges.

 We focus on diversity of thought in teams because individuals with a different background to the existing team can often spot risks or understand local trends that might be missed by others. This typically improves the group’s collective accuracy, analytical thinking and innovativeness.

 Case Study 1
 A 2018 study1 by Harvard Business Review on venture capital firms (an ideal test subject given the investments and the responsible decision makers are easily identifiable) found that diversity can improve financial performance both at the portfolio company level and on overall fund returns. Investment teams with shared school backgrounds or shared ethnicity tended to have a comparative success rate between 11-32% lower than more diverse teams.

 The study identified that success was delivered not at the stage of initial investment, but as a result of ongoing involvement of a more diverse team in later strategic decisions and recruitment, and because creative thinking is required to support the growth of young companies.

 Case Study 2
 In 2016, a Morgan Stanley study2 on more than 1,600 stocks globally found that gender diversity can lead to a 2% higher return on equity with lower volatility. Digging deeper, Morgan Stanley found that the reasons behind this better risk-adjusted return were that companies with a diverse workforce had increased productivity, better decision-making, greater innovation and higher employee retention and satisfaction. The effects of having a more diverse workforce proved beneficial to these companies.

 Case Study 3
 McKinsey have conducted a number of studies on the link between diverse leadership teams and company performance (in 2015, 2018 and 2020).

 Their 2020 study3 (conducted on 1,000 large companies in 2019 before the global pandemic) found that the link between the likelihood of financial outperformance and gender diversity / ethnic diversity has strengthened over time. Companies in the top quartile of McKinsey’s dataset for gender and ethnic diversity were more likely to have a higher earnings before interest and taxes (“EBIT”) margin than companies in the bottom quartile. The percentage of companies that demonstrate this positive relationship has risen from 15% to 25% on gender diversity and from 35% to 36% on ethnic diversity over 2014 to 2019.

 How can you assess diversity of thought in asset managers?
 Diversity should not be seen as a “tick-box” exercise and the results of these case studies show the financial benefits and impact of diversity of thought in both public and private markets. Here are our main take-a-ways you can consider when assessing diversity within your asset managers:

 Ask for indicators of diversity, such as gender and ethnicity splits of key decision-making teams in the asset management firm. How have these indicators changed over time?

 Can the asset manager supply information to support an assessment of the link between diversity and financial performance?

 Recognising that indicators are just that, can the asset manager provide case studies demonstrating how diversity of thought works in practice in their investment teams? E.g. can they provide evidence of how investment ideas are debated with examples of challenge? Such case studies are likely to highlight the better decision-making, greater innovation and higher employee satisfaction that are the leading indicators of diversity of thought.

 We believe asking these questions will encourage a greater focus on diversity of thought and help engagement with your managers.


Back to Index

Similar News to this Story

Murder on the LPI floor
DB schemes, by and large, are in a far healthier position than they have been for over a decade. This is good news, but it also changes the challenges
Pension scheme cyber attacks are you prepared
The cyber threat to pension schemes specifically is increasing. The Capita data breach in 2023 is set to cost the organisation an estimated £107 milli
Is AI the new ESG
Over the past few years, ESG was all the rage. Proponents, opponents, and everyone in between seemed to be talking about this topic on an endless loop

Site Search

Exact   Any  

Latest Actuarial Jobs

Actuarial Login

 Jobseeker    Client
Reminder Logon

APA Sponsors

Actuarial Jobs & News Feeds

Jobs RSS News RSS


Be the first to contribute to our definitive actuarial reference forum. Built by actuaries for actuaries.