Articles - Deal breaker if responsible investment expectations not met

Weakness in responsible investment (RI) is not being tolerated by professional investors, according to a 2021 client survey by Columbia Threadneedle Investments. According to the findings, RI forms an important part of the manager selection process (85%), with the majority (72%) of the institutional and wholesale investors surveyed saying that not meeting RI expectations is a “deal breaker” when considering asset managers that can help them meet their investment objectives.

 Responsible investment is seen as more than just a dedicated investment strategy

 According to the survey:
 • Eighty-six per cent of investors agree that RI is a fiduciary requirement.
 • The majority believe that it is key to pursuing financial outcomes in portfolios (77%).
 • Almost all respondents (91%) agree that RI adds value and that it enables them to meet their own clients’ evolving preferences (89%).
 • Investors also believe shareholder engagement leads to improved governance and sustainability outcomes in portfolios (91%).
 • From a thematic perspective, global water (86%), climate change (83%) and biodiversity (77%) dominate investors’ interest.

 ESG fund level reporting provides most credibility for asset managers
 When it comes to expectations and determining asset managers’ credibility in RI, a broad set of factors are considered important. Top of the list is fund-level reporting (85%) which includes a range of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) metrics. Also seen as key are a proven record in conducting effective company engagement and voting (76%), being a signatory of key voluntary codes & industry standards (73%) and the ability to support with carbon reduction within portfolios (73%).


 Investors are prepared to divest from Article 6 funds
 Evidently, managing dedicated RI strategies also plays a key role in determining asset manager credibility. In regions where the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) applies, this predominantly means offering Article 8 and 9 funds. The survey respondents expect their investment allocations to reflect this:

 • Only one third plan to hold investments in Article 6 funds by the end of 2022.
 • Almost three quarters of respondents would support a conversion from their existing Article 6 funds to Article 8 or 9. Indeed, nearly one in two are willing to divest if asset managers do not convert them. In contrast, only 8% of respondents would object to such a conversion, while 19% said they did not know.
 • There is particularly strong demand for Article 8 equity (86%) and fixed income funds (81%), with less interest in multi-asset (70%) or exclusion-based equivalents (52%). This picture is similar when it comes to Article 9 funds.

 Michaela Collet Jackson, Head of Distribution, EMEA, at Columbia Threadneedle Investments, commented on the results: “As a large global asset management firm, we recognise the responsibility and opportunity we have in driving positive change through our activities and making our own contribution to a sustainable future. Our survey shows just how important responsible investment has become in serving client needs. It’s clear that professional investors will now avoid – or even divest from – asset managers that are not meeting their RI expectations, be it by way of product offering, investment approach or client reporting. This sends a very loud message.”

 Professional investors are also increasingly seeing their own RI integration as a corporate priority. A third of respondents were already well advanced in integrating RI within their business (defined as between 75% to 100% integrated), with 80% expecting to be there by the end of 2022.

 Michaela Collet Jackson continued: “Responsible investment sits at the heart of Columbia Threadneedle’s corporate and client agenda. With the acquisition of BMO's European asset management business now complete, we can offer a market-leading RI capability based on creating value through research intensity, driving real-world change through active ownership, and partnering with clients to deliver innovative RI solutions. I thank our clients for taking part in our survey and look forward to working together to support their evolving RI objectives.”

Back to Index

Similar News to this Story

Oblivian Coalmine on pension funds fossil fuel industry ties
This new film from Make My Money Matter, starring the Academy Award winner Olivia Colman, highlights that £88 billion of UK pension savers money is in
Hopes and fears for pensions in 2024
Aon has set out its “hopes and fears” for pensions in 2024. After a year in which UK pension schemes digested the events of 2022 and adjusted themse
The lifetime pension model
In the Chancellor’s Autumn Statement Jeremy Hunt launched a call for evidence for a ‘pot for life’, also known as the lifetime pension model. As part

Site Search

Exact   Any  

Latest Actuarial Jobs

Actuarial Login

 Jobseeker    Client
Reminder Logon

APA Sponsors

Actuarial Jobs & News Feeds

Jobs RSS News RSS


Be the first to contribute to our definitive actuarial reference forum. Built by actuaries for actuaries.