By Vaibhav Agarwal, FIA Manager, Actuarial and Risk, Grant Thornton UK LLP
Consequently, (re)insurers are now considering how to reduce the time and cost spent on estimating reserves, as well as manage the level of uncertainty in their calculations.
Potentially resulting from the above, we have observed the following within the reserving processes of (re)insurers:
• Implementing data checks in R/Python, among other software
• Moving to R/Python based apps, as well as vendor solutions, to handle huge amounts of data and streamline the reserving process, which allows management to invest resources on other areas
• Implementing R/Python based models, among other software, for efficiently calculating stochastic reserves using numerous simulations
R in a nutshell
R offers several advantages – it has advanced statistical capabilities and a wide range of packages for statistical modelling and analysis. R scripts can be documented and version-controlled, ensuring reproducibility of analyses.
R is optimised for handling large datasets and performing computationally intensive tasks, making it suitable for actuarial applications. Additionally, it has an active user community, providing access to informative resources.
However, using R does require additional training for actuaries who are not familiar with programming languages. Integrating R scripts with other tools and processes used in actuarial work may also require custom solutions or additional software.
R is heavily reliant on effective data preparation - having robust measures in place is the backbone of effective reserving analysis in
R. By carefully cleaning, validating, and transforming data, actuaries can be confident that the data is fit for purpose.
Benefits of using R in deterministic methods
Chain Ladder Method:
Specialised Packages - for insurance reserving tasks, minimising manual errors, and streamlining workflows. This is particularly beneficial for smaller lines of business with limited reserve volatility and a limited need for human intervention in calculating reserves.
Data Insights - allows for the extraction of valuable insights from development triangles and the customisation of reserving calculations. Further, it generates insightful visuals that support decision-making.
Efficiency and accuracy - With just a few lines of code, users can obtain an analysis of the age-to-age development factors and the IBNR estimates, simplifying the reserving process significantly. In a relatively short time, users can navigate through the code, unlocking insights and streamlining their workflow. This rapid execution frees up valuable time for other tasks.
Bornhuetter-Ferguson (BF) method
Along with all the benefits mentioned for the Chain Ladder method, R further assists with the BF method by allowing for advanced analysis, allowing users to dive deeper into the data with sophisticated modelling and statistical tools for calculating the initial expected loss ratios (IELRs).
It offers powerful insights and customisation options, providing a pathway to more advanced analytics for determining the IELRs.
Using R in stochastic methods
Below, we have outlined the frameworks for two common stochastic methods, which you can use as a starting point to implement stochastic reserving processes or use for comparisons with existing reserves.
Bootstrapping
As part of the chain ladder function, R has an embedded bootstrapping chain ladder functionality.
As we delve deeper into the bootstrapping method, we can use the power of visualisation. Through histograms, among other visuals, we can offer stakeholders a clear and intuitive understanding of the underlying trends and patterns. These visual aids not only enhance comprehension but also assist with informed decision-making.
Multivariate analysis
In R, the wide range of statistical tools assists significantly with a multivariate analysis of risks. With options like regression analysis and cluster analysis, insurers can dive deep into their data, revealing important patterns that can influence the level of reserves held.
Among other benefits, R offers the below functionalities which make it conducive for streamlining multivariate analysis:
• A wide selection of packages dedicated to multivariate analysis, giving insurers the flexibility to explore various techniques.
• Supports advanced statistical methods essential for analysing complex data, such as linear regression and machine learning.
• Efficient and scalable, able to handle large datasets.
• Benefits from a collaborative community of users and developers, constantly improving its capabilities to meet the evolving needs of insurers.
Important considerations when using R
It's crucial to note that any changes to input assumptions necessitate a meticulous redefinition of the dependent formulas.
For instance, in a simplistic scenario where we assumed a constant IELR of 0.75 for all years, altering this assumption to, say, 0.50, mandates a recalibration or validation of formulae for both the a-priori estimated ultimate loss and the IBNR. Failure to update these formulae risks perpetuating outdated estimations, potentially misleading stakeholders.
Therefore, investing time and effort into refining these assumptions is imperative, ensuring that the insights are robust and reliable.
Conclusion
In conclusion, R presents itself as a powerful and versatile tool for actuarial reserving. Its advanced statistical capabilities, efficiency, and reproducibility make it well-suited for handling complex calculations and large datasets.
While there may be a steep initial learning curve and setup overheads, the benefits of using R for actuarial reserving outweigh these challenges.
This article represents a high-level overview, whereas there is a vast potential for further advancements and applications of R in the field of actuarial reserving. The possibilities for leveraging R in actuarial reserving are extensive, and ongoing exploration and innovation are key to unlocking its full potential in this domain.
|
