Articles - CBES report and five key indicators for insurers


The results of the 2021 Climate Biennial Exploratory Scenario (CBES) were published by the Bank of England (BoE) on 24 May 2022. What information can we glean from these results? The report covered an exercise carried out by large insurance companies and banks exploring the potential impacts of three climate change scenarios – “early transition, late transition and no additional action.” The BoE has promised individual feedback to firms who participated as part of their SS3/19 supervisory regime of management of climate risks.

 By Scott Eason FIA, Partner and Head of Insurance Consulting at BW

 However, the report provides a number of pointers towards their thinking and the direction of regulation for the insurance industry. This blog sets these out.

 1. The BoE still cares strongly about climate change risks and the potential impact on the stability of the financial system
 Whilst the impacts calculated were not huge (and it is recognised that they probably overstate impacts due to the lack of management actions), especially compared to existing risks considered in Solvency II 1 in 200-year capital calculations, the BoE sees the impacts of transition to net zero as potentially weakening firms and making them more vulnerable to other risks. It is clear they intend to continue to expect improvements in climate change risk management.

 2. Modelling capabilities are not yet thorough or flexible enough
 In particular, the BoE recognises that the third party data needed to make detailed assessments (e.g. data on counterparties’ emissions and transition plans) are not currently available and work is needed to collect that information.

 For assets, good practice is to have sector specific modelling with name specific modelling for large exposures. However, currently the assumptions on losses vary considerably between firms, with the BoE identifying 10x differences in asset price impacts for the same name.

 The report states that life insurers rely heavily on third party models, which can often be inflexible. It says the key to good modelling is the ability to identify the limitations of models and make adjustments to address these.

 Also, the BoE is keen that models can take into account changes in asset values due to changes in sentiment and expectations, not just differences in actual outcomes.

 3. The BoE is concerned about damaging consequences of blanket policies
 For example, if firms just apply blanket exclusions, firms looking to transition to important areas such as renewable energy may not get financing or insurance. This could be damaging to overall net zero ambitions and the economy.

 The BoE did state that it appears that most life insurers are not applying a divestment strategy, preferring to engage with existing counterparties.

 4. The potential inability of a large proportion of home owners to get insurance or funding
 This was the most worrying impact for me. If risks such as flood risks rise, insurance premiums may rise to be unaffordable to many. Such properties will fall significantly in value and it will be impossible to get mortgages for them. As well as being an issue for homeowners, this is clearly an issue for those issuing equity release mortgages.

 5. Whilst capital needs to reflect climate risks, it isn’t seen as the stick to make people undertake climate risk management
 The BoE is planning a research conference in Q4 2022 looking at reflecting climate change in capital requirements. However, they make the point that capital regulations are not the best way to drive reductions in emissions. A number of life insurers made the point that being forced into “green” assets could force up the prices of those assets.

 However, the BoE point to best practice being to include climate scenarios in the stress and scenario testing carried out for ORSAs. 

Back to Index


Similar News to this Story

Gaining a competitive edge by modernising policy development
Policy drafting is a fine art, and in many ways the UK insurance sector leads the world in terms of quality and clarity of consumer-facing wordings
Preview Brochure for the commercial lines event of the year
According to Deloitte’s 2022 insurance industry outlook, about one-third of the survey respondents expect revenues to be “significantly better” next y
Pensions Dashboard Webinar
Get dashboards ready and watch this recording of a webinar hosted by The Pensions Regulator and the Pensions Dashboard Programme. The webinar inclu

Site Search

Exact   Any  

Latest Actuarial Jobs

Actuarial Login

Email
Password
 Jobseeker    Client
Reminder Logon

APA Sponsors

Actuarial Jobs & News Feeds

Jobs RSS News RSS

WikiActuary

Be the first to contribute to our definitive actuarial reference forum. Built by actuaries for actuaries.